Army Regulation AR 623-3 Personnel Evaluation - Evaluation Reporting System 5 June 2012

Product Information

The first way for an Officer to appeal an OER is through something called a Commander's or Commandant's Inquiry. Essentially, if any alleged error, injustice, or inaccuracy is brought to a Commander or Commandant, he/she can conduct an inquiry to determine if relief is warranted. The Commander/Commandant in question must be above the designated rating official involved in the alleged error, injustice or inaccuracy. Any request for an inquiry must be made no later than 60 days after the signature date of the rated Soldier. The results of the inquiry will be forwarded to HQDA no later than 120 days after the signature date of the senior rater.

If the Army Special Review Board denies an OER appeal, the Officer in question can submit a subsequent appeal to the Army Board of Corrections for Military Records, using DD Form 149.

NCOER Appeal

Display the capacity to assess situations shrewdly and draw sound conclusions; form sound opinions, make sensible decisions and reliable guesses; assess the strengths and weaknesses of subordinates, peers, and enemies to create appropriate solutions and action. Officers not selected for promotion at least once, but who do not have a mandatory release date within 6 months as a result; and, Officers on a pending promotion list removal NCOs that are twice non-selected for promotion in the primary zone of consideration and are within 6 months of discharge; and, NCOs who have been selected for QMP or the Reserve/Guard equivalent (Priority 1) If an Officer receives a "referred OER," or "relief for cause OER," AR 623-3, paragraph 3-27, requires that he/she be allowed to submit a "comment" to the OER that becomes an enclosure to it. "Referred" is defined as follows:

As expressed in AR 623-3, an OER appeal needs to be well-written and supported by evidence. The assistance of a military lawyer is advisable. As expressed in AR 623-3, an NCOER appeal needs to be well-written and supported by evidence. The assistance of a military lawyer is advisable. CONSULAR PROTECTION OF FOREIGN NATIONALS SUBJECT TO THE UNIFORM CODE OF MILITARY JUSTICE {SECNAVINST 5820.6; AFR 110-13} (REPRINTED W/BASIC INCL C1) PARTICIPATION IN A MILITARY OR CIVILIAN AIRCRAFT ACCIDENT SAFETY INVESTIGATION {OPNAVIST 3750.16C, COMDTINST 5100.28, AFI 91-206} HTTPS://WWW.SECNAV.NAVY.MIL/DONI/DIRECTIVES/ THE NAVY IS THE LEAD PROPONENT FOR THIS REGULATION.Officers twice non-selected for promotion with a discharge date; Officers selected for release within 6 months by an HQDA/AGR elimination board; Officers recommended for elimination within 6 months; and, Officers notified of eligibility of an HQDA selection command board within 6 months SERVICE OBLIGATIONS, METHODS OF FULFILLMENT, PARTICIPATION REQUIREMENTS, AND ENFORCEMENT PROVISIONS DEPARTMENT OF THE ARMY INTERGOVERNMENTAL AND INTRAGOVERNMENTAL COMMITTEE MANAGEMENT PROGRAM - THIS EDITION REMAINS IN EFFECT UNTIL 16 DECEMBER 2023. JOINT TECHNICAL COORDINATING GROUP FOR MUNITIONS EFFECTIVENESS (JTCG/ME) PUBLICATIONS {AFJI 10-411; NAVMATINST 5600.23; MCO 5600.43B}